# Owner Review Disposition Decision Record V01

Issue: [#387](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/387)
Date: 2026-06-30
Repository: `pinklon/ai-capability-discipline`
Baseline commit: `cf36adeb995ab9b61f6b8eda203f9171cd5ec6ca`
Source packet: [#312](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/312)
Source PR: [#384](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/pull/384)

## Purpose

This decision record records Tony's owner-approved disposition for the 22 ambiguous closed backlog items from the #312 owner-review disposition packet.

This record is an owner-decision artifact only. It does not reopen issues, close open issues, relabel existing issues or PRs, create follow-up implementation tickets, post explanatory comments on old issues, start implementation lanes, mutate source registries, use Cloudflare CLI or API, change runtime behavior, change package authority, start Production apply, start #271 extraction-profile work, start OKF implementation, start Google SDLC implementation, or start multi-agent orchestration implementation.

Recommendations in this record are not execution. They are future owner-decision options or ticket-first routing options only.

## Baseline

| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Decision record issue | [#387](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/387) |
| Source owner-review packet issue | [#312](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/312) |
| Source owner-review packet PR | [#384](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/pull/384) |
| Source packet merge commit | `bf1dda702fb686fa7df51d50945f8c11cd1ed560` |
| Source packet head commit | `70b059c9d1eb1aede9f58e2bcd6b552f0b4ab7d3` |
| Source audit issue | [#304](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/304) |
| Follow-up ledger issue | [#310](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/310) |
| No-assumption gate issue | [#314](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/314) |
| Current work issue | [#387](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/387) |
| Baseline commit | `cf36adeb995ab9b61f6b8eda203f9171cd5ec6ca` |
| Total reviewed | 22 |
| Count discrepancy | none |

## Inputs Reviewed

- `docs/product-architecture/owner_review_disposition_packet_v01.md`
- `docs/product-architecture/owner_review_disposition_packet_v01.json`
- `docs/product-architecture/audit_recommendation_follow_up_ledger_v01.md`
- `docs/product-architecture/full_closed_backlog_implementation_reality_audit_v01.md`
- `docs/product-architecture/backlog_closure_taxonomy_and_label_governance_v01.md`
- [Issue #387](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/issues/387)
- [PR #384](https://github.com/pinklon/ai-capability-discipline/pull/384)

## Owner-Approved Disposition Summary

| Owner-approved disposition | Count |
|---|---:|
| Keep closed | 12 |
| Already covered by open parent/meta issue | 9 |
| Defer with rationale | 1 |
| Metadata cleanup only | 0 |
| Reopen | 0 |
| Spawn child issue | 0 |
| No implementation planned | 0 |

Owner-approved counts: total reviewed 22, keep closed 12, already covered by open parent/meta issue 9, defer with rationale 1, metadata cleanup only 0, reopen 0, spawn child issue 0, no implementation planned 0.

No reopen is approved from this packet. No child issue creation is approved from this packet. No relabeling is approved from this packet. No explanatory comment is approved from this packet. #254 metadata cleanup is deferred into a later broader label-hygiene pass and is not executed by this decision record.

## Owner-Approved Disposition Table For All 22 Rows

| Issue number | Issue title | Candidate disposition from packet | Owner-approved disposition | Owner decision source | Reopen approved | Child issue approved | Metadata cleanup approved | Parent/meta coverage confirmed | Required next action | Hard boundaries | Do-not-start notes |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| #254 | Authorize and execute Production NIST SSDF-only runtime activation v01 | metadata cleanup only | defer with rationale | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed; defer #254 metadata cleanup into a later broader label-hygiene pass, with no relabeling, explanatory comment, or metadata action executed by this record. | Do not reopen, relabel, comment on, or otherwise mutate #254 from this decision record. | Do not start Production apply, runtime activation, or a standalone #254 metadata cleanup ticket from this packet. |
| #94 | P1 Add AI work observability and session evidence model | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start observability implementation. |
| #84 | P1 Clarify correctness-matters AI deployment posture | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #81, #95. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start deployment-posture implementation. |
| #64 | P1: Harmonize artifact headers, chips, and search behavior across the playbook | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #40, #74. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start public-site UX work. |
| #61 | P0: Fix auto-merge lane after first codex-automerge test | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #50. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not apply codex-automerge. |
| #51 | P0: Standardize playbook navigation, search, and visual system across public artifacts | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #88. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start navigation or search implementation. |
| #44 | P0: Close out v0.9 release-integrity PR before stack integration | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start release-integrity work. |
| #43 | P2: Publish GitHub Pages stack portal and run browser QA | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #48. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start publication or browser QA work. |
| #41 | P1: Add stack release manifest, hashes, and validation scripts | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #40, #48. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start stack release-manifest work. |
| #39 | P0: Add cohesive portal, reading path, and cross-package navigation | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #48. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start portal or navigation implementation. |
| #38 | P0: Integrate stack package shell and repository structure | already covered by open parent/meta issue | already covered by open parent/meta issue | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | yes | Remain closed; treat cited open parent/meta references as controlling coverage: #37, #40, #42. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start stack package-shell work. |
| #36 | P1 Define harness and source maintenance cadence | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start maintenance-cadence implementation. |
| #29 | P0 Align release README receipt hash file and ZIP structure | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start release ZIP work. |
| #28 | P0 Fix DOCX worked-example heading numbering | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start DOCX work. |
| #27 | P0 Fix missing local HTML asset references | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start HTML asset work. |
| #26 | P0 Run three-model evaluation for v0.9 release candidate | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start evaluation work. |
| #24 | P0 Prepare v0.9 controlled-sharing release candidate | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start release-candidate work. |
| #19 | P1 Add core diagram set | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start diagram work. |
| #10 | P1-005 Add browser QA evidence | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start browser QA work. |
| #4 | P0-004 Align release labels | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start label changes from this packet. |
| #2 | P0-002 Fix search special-character handling | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start search implementation. |
| #1 | P0-001 Fix Workbench expand and collapse controls | keep closed | keep closed | Owner decision supplied in issue #387 after PR #384 merged the #312 owner-review disposition packet, approving keep-closed and parent/meta-covered sets, deferring #254 metadata cleanup, and authorizing no reopen, child issue, relabel, or explanatory-comment action. | no | no | no | not applicable | Remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory comment authorized by this record. | Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet. | Do not start Workbench implementation. |

## Items Approved To Remain Closed

The following 12 rows are owner-approved to remain closed with no immediate metadata action, no reopen, no child issue, no relabeling, and no explanatory-comment action approved by this record:

#94, #36, #29, #28, #27, #26, #24, #19, #10, #4, #2, #1.

## Items Approved As Covered By Open Parent/Meta Issue

The following 9 rows are owner-approved to remain closed and be treated as covered by the cited open parent/meta issue references:

| Issue | Controlling references |
|---|---|
| #84 | #81, #95 |
| #64 | #37, #40, #74 |
| #61 | #50 |
| #51 | #37, #88 |
| #44 | #37 |
| #43 | #37, #48 |
| #41 | #37, #40, #48 |
| #39 | #37, #48 |
| #38 | #37, #40, #42 |

## Deferred Metadata Cleanup Handling

#254 remains closed. Its metadata cleanup is deferred into a later broader label-hygiene pass. This record does not approve immediate metadata cleanup, relabeling, explanatory comments, reopening, child issue creation, Production apply, or runtime activation for #254.

## Items Not Approved For Reopen

No item from the #312 packet is approved for reopen. Reopen approved count: 0.

## Items Not Approved For Child Issue Creation

No item from the #312 packet is approved for child issue creation. Spawn child issue approved count: 0.

## Items Not Approved For Relabeling

No item from the #312 packet is approved for immediate relabeling. #254 label cleanup is deferred into a later broader label-hygiene pass.

## Items Not Approved For Explanatory Comments

No item from the #312 packet is approved for explanatory comments on old issues.

## What This Decision Authorizes

This decision authorizes only repo-local recording of the owner-approved disposition baseline from #387: keep closed for 12 issues, already covered by open parent/meta issue for 9 issues, deferred #254 metadata cleanup, zero reopen actions, zero child issue actions, zero relabel actions, and zero explanatory-comment actions.

## What This Decision Does Not Authorize

This decision does not authorize issue reopening, open-issue closure beyond normal closeout of this work issue after merge, follow-up issue creation, issue or PR relabeling, explanatory comments on old issues, source-registry mutation, Cloudflare CLI or API use, runtime behavior change, package-authority change, Production apply, #271 extraction-profile work, OKF implementation, Google SDLC implementation, multi-agent orchestration implementation, or `codex-automerge`.

## No-Assumption Gate Confirmation

The #314 no-assumption owner-clarification gate is satisfied for this bounded decision record because Tony explicitly supplied the #387 owner decision after the #312 disposition packet landed through PR #384. Candidate assumptions from #312 are treated as approved only to the extent recorded in this decision baseline. No additional implementation, relabeling, reopening, explanatory-comment, or closure action is inferred.

## Ticket-First And Anti-Manual-Toil Compliance

This decision record follows the ticket-first and anti-manual-toil controls from #308 and the operating-model continuity captured in #269 and #274. Tony was not asked to run local Git, GitHub CLI, validation, sync, cleanup, residue scan, generated artifact, draft-to-ready, or closeout commands manually.

Future metadata cleanup for #254 must wait for a broader label-hygiene pass. Future explanatory comments, relabeling, reopening, child issue creation, or implementation lanes are not authorized by this record.

## Recurrence-Prevention Control

What manual failure or repeated task did this work discover?

The #312 packet left 22 ambiguous closed-backlog rows ready for owner disposition, but without a recorded owner-approved baseline future agents could repeatedly reinterpret the candidate dispositions or start manual reopen, relabel, explanatory-comment, or child-ticket work.

What repo-local rule, validator, template field, receipt requirement, or artifact now prevents recurrence?

This decision record and its JSON companion preserve the owner-approved baseline, and `validation/scripts/check_backlog_closure_governance.py` checks the decision-record file, total reviewed count, disposition counts, no-reopen and no-child-issue approvals, #254 deferred metadata-cleanup status, recommendations-not-execution wording, ticket-first and anti-manual-toil compliance, no-assumption gate confirmation, and JSON companion contract.

If no mechanical control was added, why not?

Mechanical validation is added through `validation/scripts/check_backlog_closure_governance.py`.

## Boundary Confirmations

- No issues were reopened.
- No open issues were closed except this work issue may be closed later through its own normal PR closeout after merge.
- No follow-up implementation tickets were created.
- No existing issues or PRs were relabeled.
- No explanatory comments were posted on old issues.
- No source registries were mutated.
- No Cloudflare CLI or API was used.
- No runtime behavior was changed.
- No package authority was changed.
- No Production apply was started.
- No #271 extraction-profile work was started.
- No OKF implementation was started.
- No Google SDLC implementation was started.
- No multi-agent orchestration implementation was started.
- No `codex-automerge` action was applied.

## Recommended Next Safe Governance Lane Options

These options are not execution and do not authorize any issue, PR, runtime, source-registry, or metadata mutation:

1. Defer #254 until a later broader label-hygiene pass.
2. Record no further action for the #312 owner-review set and proceed to the next owner-selected governance lane.
3. Choose a separate governance lane through a future explicit owner decision, while preserving the no-reopen, no-child-issue, no-relabel, and no-explanatory-comment boundaries from this record.