{ "schema": "owner_review_disposition_packet_v01", "issue": 312, "date": "2026-06-30", "repository": "pinklon/ai-capability-discipline", "baseline_commit": "91c8581d0551b694cf4706677a0bfa780e2cef4e", "source_audit_issue": 304, "source_audit_pr": 305, "expected_owner_review_count": 22, "found_owner_review_count": 22, "count_discrepancy": "none", "recommendations_executed": false, "allowed_disposition_states": [ "keep closed", "reopen", "spawn child issue", "no implementation planned", "defer with rationale", "metadata cleanup only", "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner clarification required" ], "disposition_counts": { "keep closed": 0, "reopen": 0, "spawn child issue": 0, "no implementation planned": 0, "defer with rationale": 0, "metadata cleanup only": 0, "already covered by open parent/meta issue": 0, "owner clarification required": 22 }, "rows": [ { "issue_number": 254, "issue_title": "Authorize and execute Production NIST SSDF-only runtime activation v01", "closed_date": "2026-06-26", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Source/corpus inclusion only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous acceptance criteria", "ambiguous closure reason", "missing labels" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review and missing labels before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Repo-local audit says source/corpus inclusion only and recommends add labels only.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The issue should stay closed unless the owner authorizes a separate metadata cleanup action.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": true, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [ "enhancement", "priority:P1", "area:grounded-assistant", "area:data-boundary", "area:runtime-adapter", "area:grounding", "area:production-readiness", "type:operations" ], "dependency_notes": "Metadata cleanup should be owner-authorized and ticketed.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or relabel from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start Production apply or runtime activation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "metadata cleanup only", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #254 remain closed with metadata cleanup only, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: metadata cleanup only.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 94, "issue_title": "P1 Add AI work observability and session evidence model", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [ 95, 97, 98, 99 ], "audit_closure_class": "Architecture decision only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open follow-up references exist and the audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Existing follow-up references are enough for decision context, and no reopen is recommended by the audit.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start observability implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #94 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 84, "issue_title": "P1 Clarify correctness-matters AI deployment posture", "closed_date": "2026-06-20", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 81 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 81, 95 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#81 and #95 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start deployment-posture implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #84 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 64, "issue_title": "P1: Harmonize artifact headers, chips, and search behavior across the playbook", "closed_date": "2026-06-19", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37, 40 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 40, 74 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous acceptance criteria", "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37, #40, and #74 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start public-site UX work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #64 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 61, "issue_title": "P0: Fix auto-merge lane after first codex-automerge test", "closed_date": "2026-06-19", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 50 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 50 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous acceptance criteria", "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up reference exists and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to #50 unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#50 remains the controlling open reference.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not apply codex-automerge.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #61 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 51, "issue_title": "P0: Standardize playbook navigation, search, and visual system across public artifacts", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 88 ], "audit_closure_class": "Duplicate or not planned", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous acceptance criteria", "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends leaving closed if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37 and #88 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start navigation or search implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #51 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 44, "issue_title": "P0: Close out v0.9 release-integrity PR before stack integration", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent reference exists and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to #37 unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37 remains the controlling open reference.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start release-integrity work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #44 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 43, "issue_title": "P2: Publish GitHub Pages stack portal and run browser QA", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 48 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37 and #48 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start publication or browser QA work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #43 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 41, "issue_title": "P1: Add stack release manifest, hashes, and validation scripts", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37, 40 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 40, 48 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37, #40, and #48 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start stack release-manifest work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #41 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 39, "issue_title": "P0: Add cohesive portal, reading path, and cross-package navigation", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 48 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37 and #48 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start portal or navigation implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #39 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 38, "issue_title": "P0: Integrate stack package shell and repository structure", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [ 37 ], "follow_up_refs": [ 37, 40, 42 ], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "Open parent or follow-up references exist and the audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "Keep the closed issue subordinate to open parent or follow-up surfaces unless the owner directs otherwise.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "#37, #40, and #42 remain the controlling open references.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start stack package-shell work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "already covered by open parent/meta issue", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #38 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: already covered by open parent/meta issue.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 36, "issue_title": "P1 Define harness and source maintenance cadence", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Architecture decision only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found architecture-decision reality and no reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start maintenance-cadence implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #36 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 29, "issue_title": "P0 Align release README receipt hash file and ZIP structure", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Documentation only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found documentation-only reality and no reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start release ZIP work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #29 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 28, "issue_title": "P0 Fix DOCX worked-example heading numbering", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start DOCX work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #28 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 27, "issue_title": "P0 Fix missing local HTML asset references", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start HTML asset work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #27 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 26, "issue_title": "P0 Run three-model evaluation for v0.9 release candidate", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Evaluation only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found evaluation-only reality and no reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start evaluation work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #26 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 24, "issue_title": "P0 Prepare v0.9 controlled-sharing release candidate", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Source/corpus inclusion only", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found source/corpus inclusion reality and no reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start release-candidate work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #24 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 19, "issue_title": "P1 Add core diagram set", "closed_date": "2026-06-18", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start diagram work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #19 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 10, "issue_title": "P1-005 Add browser QA evidence", "closed_date": "2026-06-21", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Duplicate or not planned", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends leaving closed with an explanatory comment if owner confirms closure intent.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found duplicate-or-not-planned reality and no reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start browser QA work.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #10 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 4, "issue_title": "P0-004 Align release labels", "closed_date": "2026-06-18", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start label changes from this packet.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #4 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 2, "issue_title": "P0-002 Fix search special-character handling", "closed_date": "2026-06-18", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start search implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #2 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" }, { "issue_number": 1, "issue_title": "P0-001 Fix Workbench expand and collapse controls", "closed_date": "2026-06-18", "state_reason": "COMPLETED", "linked_prs": [], "parent_refs": [], "follow_up_refs": [], "audit_closure_class": "Needs owner review", "audit_secondary_flags": [ "ambiguous closure reason" ], "why_owner_review_required": "#304 found owner review before any reopen decision.", "current_repo_reality": "The audit recommends an explanatory comment or owner-review note.", "proposed_disposition": "owner clarification required", "rationale": "The audit found no linked parent or follow-up requiring reopen, and no immediate reopen recommendation.", "reopen_recommended": false, "follow_up_child_issue_recommended": false, "metadata_cleanup_recommended": false, "suggested_child_issue_title": "", "suggested_labels": [], "dependency_notes": "Owner may later authorize explanatory comments as metadata work.", "hard_boundaries": "Do not reopen or create child issues from this packet.", "do_not_start_notes": "Do not start Workbench implementation.", "candidate_post_clarification_disposition": "keep closed", "owner_clarification_required": true, "clarifying_question_for_tony": "Should #1 remain closed, be reopened, spawn a child issue, be marked no implementation planned, receive metadata cleanup only, or be deferred?", "candidate_assumptions": [ "Repo-local audit evidence suggests candidate post-clarification disposition: keep closed.", "This candidate is not an approved requirement until Tony confirms it or controlling repo evidence is added." ], "owner_confirmed_requirement_source": "none recorded; owner decision pending in #312" } ], "boundary_confirmations": { "issues_reopened": false, "open_issues_closed": false, "follow_up_implementation_tickets_created": false, "existing_issues_or_prs_relabeled": false, "source_registries_mutated": false, "cloudflare_cli_or_api_used": false, "runtime_behavior_changed": false, "package_authority_changed": false, "production_apply_started": false, "issue_271_started": false, "okf_implementation_started": false, "google_sdlc_implementation_started": false, "multi_agent_orchestration_started": false, "codex_automerge_applied": false }, "candidate_post_clarification_disposition_counts": { "keep closed": 12, "reopen": 0, "spawn child issue": 0, "no implementation planned": 0, "defer with rationale": 0, "metadata cleanup only": 1, "already covered by open parent/meta issue": 9 }, "owner_clarification_required_count": 22 }