{
  "artifact_id": "source-grounded-assistant-stale-issue-disposition-review-v01",
  "issue": 396,
  "date": "2026-06-30",
  "repository": "pinklon/ai-capability-discipline",
  "baseline_commit": "0ace3c76086e1de579139f7653cad4f62294b595",
  "allowed_recommendation_states": [
    "keep open",
    "close after owner approval",
    "superseded by landed work",
    "partially satisfied; narrow remaining scope",
    "umbrella review candidate",
    "defer with rationale",
    "owner clarification required",
    "keep separate for future implementation"
  ],
  "reviewed_issues": [153, 156, 159, 78, 165, 167, 169, 172, 182],
  "landed_context": [176, 187, 196, 389, 393, 395],
  "dispositions": [
    {
      "issue": 78,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "partly_satisfied_umbrella_like",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "umbrella review candidate",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "assistant_contract_design_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Use a new narrow implementation lane only if the owner wants a fresh prototype question beyond the landed proof and corpus inventory."
    },
    {
      "issue": 153,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "partly_satisfied_by_landed_contract_artifacts",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "close after owner approval",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "assistant_contract_design_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "If retained open, narrow to contract maintenance only."
    },
    {
      "issue": 156,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_or_substantially_satisfied",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "superseded by landed work",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "assistant_contract_design_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "No new lane unless the owner asks for a fresh external reference architecture revision."
    },
    {
      "issue": 159,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_or_substantially_satisfied",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "superseded by landed work",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "assistant_contract_design_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "No next implementation lane unless proxy architecture changes."
    },
    {
      "issue": 165,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_by_landed_work_and_stale_open_state",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "close after owner approval",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "proof_execution_and_smoke_test_stale_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Future proof behavior should use a new explicit issue."
    },
    {
      "issue": 167,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_by_later_deployment_and_smoke_evidence",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "close after owner approval",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "proof_execution_and_smoke_test_stale_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Future deployment work should be a new explicit operational ticket."
    },
    {
      "issue": 169,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_by_later_cloudflare_proof_and_production_evidence",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "close after owner approval",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "proof_execution_and_smoke_test_stale_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Future Cloudflare work should start from current protected production posture."
    },
    {
      "issue": 172,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "superseded_or_completed_by_smoke_evidence",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "close after owner approval",
      "classification": "bundle_candidate",
      "bundle": "proof_execution_and_smoke_test_stale_closure_bundle",
      "must_remain_separate": false,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Future provider smoke should be tied to the exact new change being tested."
    },
    {
      "issue": 182,
      "state": "OPEN",
      "disposition_status": "partly_satisfied_possible_access_umbrella",
      "recommended_owner_decision": "owner clarification required",
      "classification": "must_remain_separate",
      "bundle": null,
      "must_remain_separate": true,
      "next_implementation_lane": "Owner decision only: close as completed, retain as umbrella, or authorize a new access hardening ticket."
    }
  ],
  "bundle_candidates": {
    "assistant_contract_design_closure_bundle": [78, 153, 156, 159],
    "proof_execution_and_smoke_test_stale_closure_bundle": [165, 167, 169, 172]
  },
  "must_remain_separate_lanes": [
    "182 proof and API protection",
    "session-scoped upload or paste-source implementation",
    "corpus expansion or proof UX change",
    "provider/model configuration",
    "Cloudflare configuration"
  ],
  "non_execution_boundary": {
    "recommendations_explicitly_non_executed": true,
    "no_issue_close_or_reopen": true,
    "no_issue_or_pr_relabeling": true,
    "no_old_issue_explanatory_comments": true,
    "no_follow_up_ticket_creation": true,
    "no_source_grounded_assistant_corpus_expansion": true,
    "no_source_grounded_chat_ux_change": true,
    "no_runtime_behavior_change": true,
    "no_provider_or_model_configuration_change": true,
    "no_cloudflare_configuration_change": true,
    "no_cloudflare_cli_or_api": true,
    "no_file_upload_or_paste_source_behavior": true,
    "no_source_registry_mutation": true,
    "no_approved_source_set_mutation": true,
    "no_package_authority_change": true,
    "no_worker_webhook_scheduled_polling_or_external_queue": true,
    "no_269_or_271_reopen": true,
    "no_codex_automerge": true
  }
}